Active
3872 Erie Street
Willoughby OH, 44094
$2,400,000
Active
Commercial
Built in 1888
Discover a rare chance to invest in two exceptional properties at the heart of Downtown Willoughby, offering the perfect blend of historic charm and modern appeal. This listing includes Spirits in Willoughby, a contemporary entertainment venue, and the iconic Willoughby Coal Supply, an industrial landmark from 1888. Together, these properties offer unmatched potential to redefine hospitality and entertainment in this vibrant community.
Spirits in Willoughby is a 4,800+- SF hub of activity designed for high-capacity gatherings and diverse entertainment. With a fully equipped commercial kitchen, a horseshoe-shaped bar, Ohio Lottery Keno, and the largest patio in the district, it's tailor-made for social events, live music, and seasonal dining. Unique touches like a gazebo, fire pit, bocce courts, and a repurposed train car set this property apart, offering endless creative possibilities for future use.
Adjacent to this modern gem is the Willoughby Coal Supply, a 7,500+- SF brick structure brimming with historic character. With original wood floors, cultural significance, and a reputation as a destination for paranormal enthusiasts, this property is perfect for events, tours, or adaptive reuse. Its fenced outdoor space, ample parking, and connection to community programs add even more versatility.
Strategically located in the Entertainment District and surrounded by thriving developments, these properties offer boundless opportunities. Whether you envision a boutique hotel, craft beverage destination, or event venue, this pairing is positioned to set a new standard for experiences in Downtown Willoughby. Don't miss your chance to bring this transformative vision to life!
5089033
MLSⓇ ID
December 7, 2024
Listed
December 7, 2024
Updated
Map
3872 Erie Street
Willoughby OH, 44094
Interior Features
Fireplace
No
Cooling
Yes
Cooling Description
Central Air, Ceiling Fan(s), Other
Heating
Yes
Heating Description
Baseboard, Electric, Forced Air, Gas
Exterior/Building Features
Lot Size
1.53 Acres
Sewer
Public Sewer
School Information
School District
Willoughby-Eastlake - 4309
Other Property Details
Taxes
$6,332
Tax Frequency
Annually
Days on Market
1
Garage
No
Parking
Additional Parking, On Site
View
No
County
Lake
Municipality
Willoughby
Water Source
Public
Pool
No
Courtesy of Keller Williams Citywide
All information deemed reliable but not guaranteed and should be independently verified. All properties are subject to prior sale, change or withdrawal. Neither listing broker(s) nor Michelle Federico shall be responsible for any typographical errors, misinformation, misprints and shall be held totally harmless.
©2025 Yes Multiple Listing Service, Inc. All rights reserved.